Mushroom Popcorn

$2.99 - $31.99
(41 reviews) Write a Review
Mushroom popcorn is unique because it pops into a circular or mushroom shape and is larger and crunchier than our other varieties. Mushroom popcorn is perfect for fun recipes like caramel corn and pairs well with our spices and glazes. 
This popcorn is not hulless like our Baby WhiteMedium White, and Ladyfinger varieties. For best results, Mushroom popcorn should be popped at a higher temperature. This creates more mushroom-shaped kernels and leaves less unpopped corn. 

41 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    My Favorite

    Posted by Monique P. on Jul 9th 2022

    I bought a variety of kernels here at Amish County and I would proudly say this is my all time favorite popcorn now. This taste is similar to Orville Red.'s tender white. The kernels when popped are about double the size of a standard/traditional popcorn, which holds favoring better. Though, I didn't use heavy seasoning, I think a buttery flavor comes through. I just added the ballpark salt (sold here) and mixed veg. oil to pop. I then mixed very little topping oil to the popcorn. I highly recommend this product, I have since ordered 3 bottles of the mushroom kernels.

  • 5
    Mushroom Popcorn

    Posted by Michael Bernstein on Jun 22nd 2022

    To start with, Amish Mushroom Popcorn is the best I've ever eaten. I've been eating popcorn for 65 years. I was excited to learn I could buy Mushroom popcorn . I really enjoyed it. Then my hot air popper pooped out. Well now with my new hot air popper, the quality, size and almost every kernel pops....I'm in seventh heaven. I only wish I could have discovered Mushroom popcorn decades ago. Thank you so much !

  • 5
    Popping method makes big difference!

    Posted by Debbie on Feb 24th 2022

    We love this popcorn - now that we pulled out the air popper. Virtually every kernel popped and the majority were ball shaped. The texture it terrific. We had been popping it in a pan with oil. With the pan method, we were not so happy with the results. If your having problems with this type, try a different popping method!

  • 5
    Great Popcorn

    Posted by Ginette Murray on Jan 18th 2022

    Great Popcorn, nice and big when popped. I buy for our concession stand at school and this has been the best result for us!

  • 5
    Best popcorn ever

    Posted by Jennifer on Nov 10th 2021

    We are huge popcorn fans and this is the best kind we've ever found! It's like a meal.

  • 3
    Small amount of mushroom popcorn

    Posted by CSN on Jul 12th 2021

    This is my first purchase of mushroom popcorn. I was expecting that most of these kernels would pop in mushroom popcorn. Boy was I wrong. I would say one in every 5 (at most) kernels are mushroom, the rest don't look any different that the Orville Redenbacher popcorn kernels I bought at the grocery store. I was hoping for something better. I'm not sure if this is normal, but it's definitely disappointing. The popcorn tastes ok.

  • 5
    Mushroom Popcorn is amazing

    Posted by Kathleen Brock on Jul 3rd 2021

    The volunteer fire department that my husband works with had a 4th of July fundraiser with kettle corn and popcorn. We ordered the 25lb of mushroom popcorn and WOW. First ordering is easy and shipping was right on time. The best part is the popcorn. I am sitting here watching it pop at the fundraiser and it is beautiful. Big, fluffy, and amazingly tender. There is very little waste. This is the official new popcorn of the Lillian Volunteer Fire Department.

  • 2
    Big kernels, big hulls

    Posted by Andrea on Nov 30th 2020

    I bought a variety pack. This indeed does pop into large ball or mushroom shaped pieces but it’s a bit stale I. Texture and the hulls are huge get stuck in my teeth.

  • 5
    Mushroom Popcorn

    Posted by Paul Smith on May 2nd 2020

    I am 65 years and have loved popcorn all of my life. My wife and I have it almost every night. This is by far the best popcorn I have ever eaten. I wish I had found this site years ago.

Adding to cart… The item has been added

Videos Hide Videos Show Videos

Try it this way!

Some popcorn varieties are better suited for certain recipes than others. Below are just a few ideas of how you can use this type of popcorn to create a unique treat.

Popcorn, FAQs
& more!

Popping Tips


Rates + Information

made easy!

Microwave Popcorn