Buttery Popcorn Topping (Gallon)

(8 reviews) Write a Review
Only ships to lower 48 States. Cannot be shipped to PO boxes.

This is the topping to use for pouring over your popped popcorn to get that rich buttery flavor! If you think that a pint of Buttery Topping is too small, try this gallon size.


Ingredients: soybean oil, palm oil, artificial butter flavor, TBHQ and citric acid (added as an antioxidant), beta-carotene (added for color), and dimethyl polysiloxane (added as an antifoam agent)


This item does not need to be refrigerated. Please store in a cool, dry place for maximum freshness. 


8 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Best popcorn oil ever!

    Posted by Nikole on Oct 3rd 2021

    This stuff is truly the best I’ve ever tasted. You can't go wrong with this one. I love it, love it, love it!

  • 5
    better than "named brands"

    Posted by Barbara Hood on Mar 26th 2018

    got a gal of this in early Jan this year - what other reviewers wrote is true, higher quality, better tasting - wrote before - will write again - wish you had some health ingred. info on the label - lack there of makes me think might be much worse for me- if the ingredients "didn't scare me" - I might use more - to the Amish Country Popcorn People - if you would email the info I sure would appreciate it.

  • 5
    light and buttery

    Posted by Barbara Hood on Jan 21st 2018

    Had it for the first time yesterday - was noticeably lighter and more delicate in flavor than the brands I have been buying in the grocery store - 13 oz size.. appreciated other reviews.- any up side or down side to storage? My label doesn't look like the one in the pic - mine has much less info - says only Amish Country Popcorn Gallon Buttery Topping - what it's made from, calories, fat %, etc would be more helpful. Welcome any feedback on my queries.

  • 5
    pure unadulterated awesomeness!!!!

    Posted by AMY on Jun 2nd 2017

    I've been using this product for years, purchasing it through a local mennonite market. I had recently purchased a counter sized popcorn machine, I looked on the side of the bottle of topping I had and found the website, ordered and it came quickly. I have even gotten the car dealership I work for using it! We will be ordering regularly!!

  • 5
    The Best Bar None

    Posted by Bill Rodgers on Apr 14th 2017

    Our family absolutely LOVES the Buttery Topping. We have tried numerous Major brands before trying this. Nothing else comes close. This is the closest to real butter we have found. We bought bottles for 4 of our friends to try and they are sold too!

  • 5

    Posted by Joanna Hall on Mar 8th 2017

    Love this amd it doesn't take much at all!

  • 5
    Excellent popcorn topping

    Posted by Melissa on Feb 15th 2017

    I tried this in the smaller bottle, and enjoyed it so much I bought the gallon size. We've tried other toppings, but everyone prefers this. I've even done blind taste tests, and the Amish Country Buttery Topping always wins. It has a nice butter flavor and just makes perfect movie theater popcorn.

  • 5
    Best popcorn topping ever!!!

    Posted by ratherbfishing on Jan 5th 2017

    I have tried numerous types of popcorn butter toppings from other manufactures and nothing compares to this. If you want true movie theater popcorn taste at home you will not be disappointed.

Adding to cart… The item has been added